{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

Over the past three years, home prices across the United States consistently surpassed previous year levels. However, this trend has come to an end. In October, national statistics revealed that the median home sale price dropped slightly below the year-ago figure, marking the first annual decline since spring 2023. Concurrently, the inventory of homes for sale reached its highest point since early 2020, while pending sales fell to their lowest level in more than ten years, outside of the early pandemic period. Notably, around 20% of listings have seen price reductions.

To complicate matters, borrowing costs have risen again. The average interest rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% range within just a week, following a brief period of improvement. Therefore, while buyers may have increased negotiation power, many households find their monthly payments challenging.

This scenario presents a unique opportunity. Sellers are experiencing a decrease in offers and longer listing durations, leading to list prices and sale conditions being viewed more as starting points than final figures. If you are considering purchasing a home this winter, here's what you might negotiate and how to approach this with your agent and lender.

Understanding the Implications of a Minor Price Decline

A national price drop of less than half a percent is not indicative of a market crash, nor does it signal that all areas are seeing price reductions. High-price coastal regions with limited inventory continue to show solid gains, while numerous large metropolitan areas in the South and West have seen declines of several percentage points compared to last year. Thus, your local market is far more significant than national trends.

The national figures suggest a shift in market dynamics. As homes sit unsold longer and listings multiply against a shrinking buyer pool, sellers may become more amenable to negotiations. This adaptability can manifest in both price adjustments and favorable sale terms.

Price is Just One of Many Factors

While many buyers focus predominantly on the sale price, in a high-interest environment, the overall monthly payment and the cash needed at closing can be considerably more significant. A few thousand dollars off the listed price results in only a fractional reduction in the loan amount. Allocating that same sum in other ways can frequently benefit your budget more significantly. Here are common negotiation points in a slower market:

  • A lower purchase price compared to the list price
  • A seller credit to offset closing costs
  • Completion of repairs before closing or a credit instead of repairs
  • Seller-funded assistance to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing date or move-in schedule that suits your needs
  • Inclusions such as appliances or window coverings

Your agent is familiar with how local sellers are reacting and can guide you on which items to prioritize in your proposal. The aim isn't to request everything but to focus on those aspects that truly matter to you.

Credits for Closing Costs Can Alleviate Cash Constraints

Closing costs typically account for a few percentage points of the loan amount, in addition to your down payment. This can pose challenges for many first-time buyers trying to gather enough cash. A seller credit can directly cover some of those costs, reducing the amount you need to bring to closing.

Bear in mind that there are limits. Loan programs often cap the contribution from the seller, typically somewhere between 3% and 9% depending on the loan type and the size of your down payment, and credits generally cannot exceed the actual closing costs. Consult your lender early on to understand the specifics of your loan to ensure any requests in your offer are permissible.

How a Rate Buydown Operates

With interest rates climbing beyond 7%, assistance with your rate might be one of the best offerings a seller can make. There are primarily two types of buydowns.

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to secure a lower rate for the lifetime of the loan. Each point costs 1% of the loan amount, with the rate discount varying by lender and market dynamics. If you plan to hold the loan for several years, a permanent buydown could be advantageous.

A temporary buydown lowers your payment for the initial year or two. A common scenario sees the rate reduced by two percentage points the first year and one point the second, settling at the full rate thereafter. For instance, on a $350,000 30-year loan at approximately 7.34%, monthly principal and interest would be around $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the first-year payment could be around $1,952 and the second-year payment about $2,176, before returning to the full payment in the third year. This arrangement might cost over $8,000, which a seller might prefer to cover rather than discounting the sale price equivalently.

It's important to realize that a temporary buydown is not a long-term solution. You still have to be comfortable with the full payment after the discounted period, and lenders usually qualify you based on the full rate. If interest rates decrease in the future, refinancing might be an avenue, but the timing and occurrence of such a change remain uncertain.

Don't Forego the Inspection for Competitiveness

In a vigorous market, many buyers waived inspections or limited their requests to enhance their chances in a bidding war. However, in a slower market, such sacrifices are not necessary. A comprehensive home inspection is crucial for understanding the property's condition, including the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical work, and foundation, before making a commitment.

If issues arise during the inspection, your agent can advise you on seeking repairs, a price adjustment, or a credit. Opting for a credit can offer more control compared to seller-managed repairs, allowing you to choose who undertakes the work and how it is handled, though the best approach depends on the specific problem and your loan's stipulations.

Ensure Your Financing Is in Order First

Having strong negotiation leverage is meaningless if your financing isn't solid. A seller considering multiple offers will typically lean towards the buyer who appears most reliable. Before diving into the market, obtain full preapproval rather than simply a quick prequalification, identify your maximum comfortable monthly payment instead of just your highest loan amount, and compare estimates from different lenders. Inquire with each lender about their handling of seller credits or buydowns to avoid any unexpected developments later.

Key Questions to Review with Your Agent

  • What is the average duration homes remain on the market in this area, and how frequently are prices being adjusted?
  • Would lowering the price, securing a closing cost credit, or pursuing a rate buydown offer me the best budget relief?
  • How do the condition and history of this specific home influence my negotiation requests?
  • Which contingencies should I retain in my proposal to safeguard my interests?

The Overall Takeaway

Although a softer market doesn't equate to lower buying costs, especially with rising mortgage rates, it does afford prepared buyers the chance to customize a deal that aligns with their financial situation. With reliable financing, a clear understanding of what matters most to you, and expert guidance from your agent and lender, you could potentially negotiate terms far better than what was possible a year or two prior.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message